Saturday, November 5, 2011
The non monetised sector of the economy
--- In WSM_Forum@yahoogroups.com, "Bob Howes (vegan)" <robertcircle1@...> wrote:
>
> Hi Robin,
>
> I agree with you that there are classes but I also think we should all become a third class, a classless class. We don't need to wait for a socialist revolution either, we can just enter into different relationships with each other for mutual advantage. Maybe even in the same ratio of rich to poor in society. If 99 of us join together and largely cater to our own needs then maybe we can get one uber rich person to join us. What do you think? It would be a hell of a boost wouldn't it?
>
> Cheers,
>
> Bob
> ***
>
Bob,
There'as nothing wrong with people wanting to change their relationship with others for the purposes of "mutual advantage". To an extent, people have always done this throughout the history of capitalism. There has always been what economists have dubbed an informal non-monetised "grey" economy, the size of which, in terms of comparative labour hours expended, is literally massive. So really you are pushing on an open door here...
Some years ago a guy by the name of Charles Handy wrote a book called "The Future of Work" . Citing earlier research by Richard Rose, Handy noted that within the United Kingdom as a whole the proportion of labour hours devoted to unpaid work of all kinds - namely, 51% - exceeded the total labour hours worked in paid employment in both the official white money economy (46%) and the unofficial or illegal black money economy (3%) combined. (Handy C, The Future of Work, Basil Blackwell, Oxford 1984, p.48) . In other developed economies these proportions were somewhat different - in Italy, for example, a larger proportion was accounted for by the black economy and a smaller proportion by the white economy. I guess thats the hand the Mafia at work there ;-)
In America, Scott Burns, referred to the vast scale of the "domestic self provisioning" sector in these terms:
"How large would this invisible economy be if it could be measured in dollars? Very large. According to one study (Sirageldin, 1969), the total value of all the goods and services produced by the household economy in 1965 was about $300 billion. That was about equal to the gross national product of the Soviet Union at that time. If all the work done within the household by men and women were monetised, the total would be equal to the entire amount paid out in wages and salaries by every corporation in the United States...Very very little of this appears in conventional accountings for the the gross national product...The hours of work done outside the money economy rival those done inside" (Burns S, The Household Economy: Its Shape, Origins and Future, Beacon Press, Boston, 1975, p.6-8)
Though these figures are somewhat dated they do not seem to have changed much over time. According to more recent figures released by United Nations Development Programme, for the industrialised countries as a whole, the consensus seems to be that as much time is spent on unpaid work as on paid work . (The North-South Institute Newsletter Vol.3, No.2 , 1999). More recently still, a report on the State of the World Population (2002) by UNFPA notes that "Of men's total work time in industrial countries, roughly two thirds is spent in activities that are counted towards measures of GNP and one third in unpaid activities; for women, the shares are reversed" (http://www.unfpa.org/swp/2002/english/ch4/page3.htm). This works out to be much the same as 50:50 split between paid and unpaid work mentioned earlier.
So, yes, people do relate to others in ways quite different to that prescribed by capitalism - not only in terms of the domestic household but in numerous other forms of voluntary or unpaid work -from charities to mutual aid projects to the myriad of schemes such as the "Freecycle network" . This last scheme started off as one person's idea in Tucson USA back in 2003 and mushroomed in a matter of a few years into a global network of well over 8 million people in 85 countries and is still growing at a phenomenal pace. There is even a group here in Granada , Spain
So, yes, you dont need to tell me or anyone else that it is possible. The facts speak for themselves. The potential is there.
However, the flipside of that coin is to recognise also what is NOT possible and why precisely therefore a socialist revolution is most definitely needed. Some kinds of means of production are amenable to what you suggest; others most definitely are not. Factories, power stations and the like are clearly not and we can't do without them , can we? The computer that you are typing your emails on is assembled out of components and materials that are produced within the capitalist monetary economy. Certainly, if the computer crashes you can get it repaired without money changing hands - for example, if you are a member of a LETS group. Thats fine as far as it goes but its not going to alter that fact it is within the commercial capitalist sector that this computer first saw the light of day.
Point is that capitalism NEEDSA us to be its wage slaves, to have no option but to sell our working abilities on the labour market so that capital can reproduce itself. Its needs us in other words to be saparated from the means of the production so that become dependent on those who actually own and control these means of production for a job. There are all sorts of ways in which workers are sucked into dependency on the money economy. Dave mentioned taxes. Historically , taxes played an important role in forcing native populations in the European colonies into migrant labour. Hut taxes in the native reserves of South Africa, payable in money, compelled many black workers into working on the mines. The reduction in the amount of land available for black subsistence agriculture (formalised in the 1913 Native Lands Act) put added pressure on them, literally leaving them with no alternative but to migrate to places like Johannesburg to work as cheap mine labour
This is what we need to recognise and construct our strategy around. The complete elimination of capitalism can ONLY come through a social revolution. It can't happen in any other way. Yes there are some things you can do that dont require you to wait for a socialist revolution but equally there are other things that cannot be done UNLESS and UNTIL we have a socialist revolution! Its a question of sorting out which is which.
Capitalism is not going to conveniently submit itself to a process of non-market entryism, as it were, in the way that trotskyists a few years back thought they could change the Labour Party through entryism. All that happened is that the Trots got booted out.
In the capitalist sector of the economy for all the backward looking nostalgia of the freemarket neanderthals on this list, who seemingly yearn for the return of an era of petty commodity production (if it ever really existed) a few ceturies ago, capital is becoming progressively concentrated in few and fewer hands. A tiny portion of the population own more and more of the large scale means of production. This has got nothing to do with economies of scale, with factories getting larger and larger. Factories can reduce in size, corporations can scale down and federate into more autonomously run units but STILL the concentration of capital goes on. According the 2010 Global Wealth Report 83% of the world's households own only 13% of the wealth, down from 14% the previous year. By contrast, the top 0.5% of households (those with $5 million or more) owned 21%, or $23 trillion, of the world's wealth. That is up from 19% in 2008. If this is not a concentrating trend, what is?
This is what we have to face up to and confront. And you can get rid of the stranglehold that this tiny class of individuals exercise over our lives ONLY by deliberately and consciously stripping them of their monopoly ownership of the means of production - means of production which we ourselves, the vast majority, produced in the first place and from which we are systematically and forcibly excluded in the interests of capital accummulation
Robin
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Followers
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(8499)
-
▼
November
(1134)
- रीटेल एफ डी आई से कारोबार पर विदेशी पूंजी काबिज और...
- ‘MINDCONTROL’ AND ELECTRONIC WEAPONS - VICTIMS' OR...
- Welcome to the world of corporate psychopaths
- Financial 'vultures' poised to swoop on Africa thr...
- MEDVEDEV: RUSSIA SERVES NOTICE November 28, 2011 B...
- Nepal Updates
- Statement Condemning Repression Against Anti POSCO...
- he GOP’s Middle Class Tax Increase
- F-22s Gobble Up More Billions
- Adivasi Bounded Labour Killed,No Justice yet.-Than...
- US war against Pakistan?
- PIL to Register FIR Against Mukesh Ambani, RIL
- The lawsuit that could end the gangster rule of We...
- Throw These Cooking Oils in the Trash
- Retail FDI: The Calculations and Compulsions..
- Manual scavengers poster -READ
- Irula Tribe women sexualy abused by Police - Tiruk...
- Sr. Valsa case with the National Commission for Women
- Oh The aggressors! Oh The killers of the Innocent ...
- MY AUSTRIA VISIT AND PROJECT OF HOPE Asghar Ali En...
- Fwd: BAMCEF & RMS 28TH N.C. 24TH TO 28TH DEC 2011,...
- Fwd: [OrissaConcerns] Statement on the Repression ...
- Fwd: declare aadhaar illegal, pleads suit - bangal...
- Fwd: [bangla-vision] FD News and an important action
- Fwd: हस्तक्षेप.कॉम चल अन्ना घर आपने रेन भई यह देश…
- Fwd: Tom Burghardt: Target Iran - Washington's Cou...
- Fwd: Kanimozhee bhee Kaanee ho Gayee!
- Fwd: Truth behind the appeal to Hindus - One secon...
- Fwd: (Desiyatra)-- Sharad slap unites Indian polit...
- Fwd: Today's Exclusives - Controversial stock oper...
- In Tamil Nadu’s southern districts, prisoners are ...
- Fishy Friends By Nigar Ataulla
- Rapid Haramikaran Of India - Growth Rate Food 2%, ...
- Dalit labourer dies, nephew alleges he was beaten
- Water politics in the Jordan River basin
- Dr. Bhupen Hazarika honoured in London - 1999
- declare aadhaar illegal, pleads suit - bangalore, ...
- DGP Mr. BR Lall – Crusader Against ‘Black Money’ N...
- The glimpses of Post FDI in retail
- Anand Sharma writes to parties clarifying FDI stance
- The Miqati Government in Lebanon – Continued Subju...
- Miami-protest spokesman led 'Nuke Israel' rally
- Why not open debate on Holocaust?+Capitalism under...
- Discussion on Karnataka Guarantee of Services to C...
- Statue of Liberty – an Egyptian Peasant Lady?
- Moroccan opposition warns of silent majority
- De Jager talks tough as he heads to Berlin for tal...
- Debt Crisis Belgium under the tutelage of Brussels?
- Eurobond talk should not be 'taboo', Monti tells V...
- Will Global Financial Demolition Lead To New World...
- Would uranium sales to India breach a key Labor tr...
- Fwd: [Occupy Kolkata] i know casteism in india is ...
- Fwd: [Marxistindia] CPI(M) Supports Traders Call f...
- Fwd: Julie Lévesque: Protest in Syria: Media Lies ...
- Fwd: [Occupy Delhi] IN 1886-94, DURING THE SANTHAL...
- Fwd: [Occupy Delhi] PROGRESSIVE DEMOCRATIC STUDENT...
- Bangladesh: International anti-imperialism conference
- 5,000,000 North East Indian Migrations Expected in...
- Prosecutor: Reagan, Bush not criminally liable
- LIVING IN GERMANY
- Occupy Everywhere: Michael Moore, Naomi Klein on N...
- The People's Surveillance State
- Washington's $8 Billion Shadow
- Where Does Occupy Wall Street Go From Here? ...a p...
- Israel's technology or its politics that the minis...
- Targeted Individual due for execution unless we dr...
- FDI in Retail for 99% Indians – Vendors, Farmers, ...
- HUNDREDS RALLY IN MUZAFFARABAD AGAINST MFN STATUS ...
- KSA: Thousands in Eastern Province Chant Death to ...
- LIBYA: Thousands accused of Gaddafi links held by ...
- RSS A pure religion- LIKE SIKHS/Jaina/ BUDHA/= wit...
- Dead Man Talking: More Fake Encounters in Gujarat
- 21st Greatest Sikh Traitor Parkash Chand Badal ina...
- Up to 25 Pak soldiers dead in NATO chopper attack
- Abhay Sahu, leader of anti-POSCO movement arrested
- login immediately Meshram saheb speaking
- Nuclear emergency in Japan: lessons for India
- DRUM- Desis Rising Up & Moving
- World's Largest and Longest Invisible War
- Regards to PIL- Chinese expert praises Indian courts-
- Non-discrimination and Equality in India Contestin...
- Akal Takht, SGPC condemn slapping of Sharad Pawar
- Urbanization key to speedy growth: RBI governor
- Egypt's economy slumps under weight of unrest
- FDI decision taken to help Rahul's foreign friends...
- Kishenji's body identified by niece
- aviation crisis News Stories
- KISHENJI SPECIAL Calcutta Corner Why is Mamata Ban...
- Bring the spice back The men have left the Sunderb...
- Maoists allege fake encounter PRONAB MONDAL
- Blunted: Maoist peril & CPM slur - CM scores twin ...
- Hunt for Suchitra yields purse NARESH JANA
- State to fly Kishan’s body home if identified by n...
- http://www.telegraphindia.com/1111126/jsp/frontpag...
- Egg on the face of fake Tagore champions - All 20 ...
- State steps up border vigil Police escort for fore...
- Kishan wily, govt wilier Parivartan and penetratio...
- Reforms Drive is in Topmost Gear Now in Absence of...
- Fog effect: 28 trains to remain cancelled for two ...
- ISHRAT JAHAN: MURDER IN COLD BLOOD Ram Puniyani
-
▼
November
(1134)
No comments:
Post a Comment