http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/sunday-toi/all-that-matters/Dont-change-N-liability-law-to-suit-MNCs/articleshow/16509494.cms
Don't change N-liability law to suit MNCs
Jim Riccio | Sep 23, 2012, 01.42AM IST
Nuclear power is dangerous and meltdowns are expensive. Nuclear power
is so dangerous that the corporations that build nuclear reactors
would not do so unless they were protected from the liability of a
nuclear accident. As the world has witnessed in Japan, the cost of a
nuclear accident far outstrips the insurance coverage governments have
jerry-rigged for the benefit of the nuclear industry. Ultimately, the
public is left holding the radioactive bag and billions of dollars in
accident clean-up costs.
Without an insurance scheme that shifts liability from the corporation
to the public, the nuclear industry would never have split the first
atom. After the Fukushima disaster, Vermont Law School Institute for
energy and the environment researcher Mark Cooper stated that: "If the
owners and operators of nuclear reactors had to face the full
liability of a Fukushima-style nuclear accident or go head-to-head
with alternatives in a truly competitive marketplace, unfettered by
subsidies, no one would have built a nuclear reactor in the past, no
one would build one today, and anyone who owns a reactor would exit
the nuclear business as quickly as possible."
Cooper found that without such insurance schemes "nuclear power is
neither affordable nor worth the risk."
In 2010, India passed the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act.
Since then, foreign corporations and the governments that represent
them have pressured the Indian government to amend the Act. Unlike
other liability regimes adopted by nuclear nations, the Indian law
allows those corporations that supply nuclear reactors to be held
accountable in the event of a meltdown. The Nuclear Liability Act
provides the nuclear plant operator a 'right of recourse' and this has
made foreign nuclear corporations nervous.
Nuclear salespersons and statesmen, from Areva's "Atomic Anne"
Lauvergeon to US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, have
lobbied India to amend its Act. And Russia has recently requested that
India waive its Nuclear Liability Act for the two Russian reactors
being built at the Kudankulam nuclear power plant. It seems American,
French and Russian corporations want to sell India billions of dollars
worth of new nuclear reactors; they just don't want to be held
accountable for the damages their nuclear reactors can cause.
Rather than rewrite the Nuclear Liability Act, the rules implementing
it have drastically diluted the liability of the reactor supplier.
Fortunately, as the world's largest democracy, India is uniquely
situated to defeat and deflect these attempts to water down the law.
The parliamentary standing committee has identified inconsistencies
between the Act and the rules implementing it and has asked the
department of atomic energy to go back to the drawing board and
establish rules that are consistent with the intent of the Nuclear
Liability Act. This is a step in the right direction and will serve to
better protect the lives and livelihoods of Indian citizens.
India's Nuclear Liability Act should not be altered or subverted to
benefit Areva, General Electric Hitachi, Westinghouse or Rosatom.
These corporations have been coddled by their own domestic and
international regimes that channel legal and economic liability for a
nuclear accident away from the nuclear supplier and to the owner of
nuclear plant. In the Indian context, these are public companies and
so the ultimate burden would fall on the tax payer.
But, as is evident after the accident at Fukushima, no nuclear plant
owner can withstand the financial tsunami of a nuclear meltdown.
TEPCO, the owner of the Fukushima nuclear plant is now bankrupt,
virtually a ward of the state. General Electric, the corporation that
designed the reactors that melted down and then blew up, turned a $5
billion profit in 2011. Even if the faulty GE designed reactors
contributed to Fukushima disaster, Japanese law fails to hold the
nuclear vendor accountable.
Fukushima has again shown that splitting atoms to generate electricity
is inherently dangerous. If corporations want to sell nuclear
reactors, they should be held accountable for the damage their reactor
can cause. The Indian Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act corrects
this glaring omission in international liability regimes. Nuclear
power has proven to be more peril than promise and those who would
profit from promoting it should be held accountable.
The writer is a nuclear policy analyst for Greenpeace in Washington DC
Wednesday, September 26, 2012
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Followers
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(6784)
-
▼
September
(259)
- यूपीए और राजग संसदीय नौटंकी के बाद अमेरिकी हितों क...
- Free market economy is injected with reform cromin...
- Naming of Shadman Chowk, Lahore as Bhagat Singh Ch...
- Jal Satyagraha
- In a country where anyone earning Rs 22 per day is...
- Bt.cotton failure : Seven Vidarbha Farmers suicide...
- Egypt, Yemen challenge some U.S. ideas
- As crimes against Dalits rise, UP tops the chart -
- Illegal cracker units exploit Deepavali sales
- Do You Think That America is Not a Police State Yet?
- Nuclear Disarmament Disarmed
- Not vegetarianism or dieting, Mr. Modi INDIRA HIRWAY
- oint letter from Japanese Anti Nuclear Activists a...
- Video:- "The Toronto Hearings on 9/11" - Brilliant
- Dalit kids served injustice at MP school
- Community Formation and Communal Conflict-Namasudr...
- विकास की गंगा की बाढ़ में डूब रहा एक गांव
- शहर और देहात तथा मानसिक श्रम और शारीरिक श्रम के वि...
- Mr. Thackeray! Who is in Whose Land?
- ईमानदारी भुनाने के लिए बाजार चाहिए, वरना जियेंगे क...
- ममता की राजनीति चाहे जो हो,दिल्ली में प्रतिरोध की ...
- No option but to wait for Mamata`s national mass m...
- Fwd: press note by Nikhat Parwen wife of Fashih Ma...
- Fwd: Bhagat Singh Birth celebration in Lahore, pho...
- Fwd: (हस्तक्षेप.कॉम) हे प्रभु भाजपा की रक्षा करना
- बाजरी और हाजरीhttp://www.jansatta.com/index.php/co...
- उत्पीड़न के बहाने
- ‘Perfect storm’ that shook PM Grim alert, bitter p...
- Fw: Press Conference on Hunger Deaths and National...
- Libya: End of the Honeymoon Period
- Egypt's Sinai: The Collapsing Buffer Zone between ...
- UAE Islamist group denies reports it has an armed ...
- Why Qatar wants to invade Syria
- Sectarian Violence in Burma Attracting the Attenti...
- George Habash: A Profile From the Archives
- The plight of the Rif: Morocco's restive northern ...
- Bahrainis battle police in anti-government protests
- Is Jordan heading for chaos? The royal court's unw...
- Analysis: The winds of change in Sudan By Sudan Ch...
- Who are Tunisia's Salafis?
- Saudi Arabia and Qatar Dueling Monarchies Of The M...
- Mauritania: Dreaming about the Fall of the Militar...
- A threat to the entire country Who and what is Bok...
- Rani Rasmani on her 220th birth anniversary
- Rani Rasmani on her 220 th birth anniversary!
- जीने नहीं देती तो सब्सिडी क्यों देती है सरकार
- Cut throat economists push for ethnic cleansing.Co...
- BARVE'S EXPULSION FROM BAMCEF
- हवा और पानी की नीलामी नहीं होगी, यूं ही बेच दी जाय...
- बांग्लादेश में हाशिये पर है हिन्दू आबादी
- Agenda to destroy agrarian India!Land Bill diluted...
- Fwd: [initiative-india] Press Release : MoRD Furth...
- Fwd: Shahid Bhagat Singh's birth anniversary: Pak ...
- Ethnic politics: Baloch, Sindhi and Mohajir moveme...
- s Iraq's Dawa Party Returning To Their Islamist Ro...
- Kenya and its coastal discontents Kenya must make ...
- How to kill the Haqqanis? Work with Iranian terror...
- Outrage at CIA's deadly 'double tap' drone attacks...
- Towards a "Colored Revolution" in Malaysia? US and...
- Egypt Workers Striking in Record Numbers
- Interview with Islamic Group leader Rifai Taha
- Could Benghazi Embassy Deaths Be a Harbinger of Al...
- 100 Million Dead, Trillion of Dollars Lost from Cl...
- FIELD MARSHAL SAM MANEKSHAW’S LECTURE AT DEFENCE S...
- Are you going to Kudankulam?
- India: big bang, or parting shot? By Victor Mallet
- THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS CRITICIZES GOVT ...
- अब बिजली गिरेगी आम आदमी पर! बिजली ग्रिड फेल होने ...
- Deprived of food security in grow
- Fwd: (हस्तक्षेप.कॉम) यूरोपीय विश्व दृष्टि की देन ह...
- Fwd: [initiative-india] NAPM pays respect and homa...
- Fw: [pmarc] Fwd: Gujarat genocide 2002: Commemorat...
- Fw: Hindutva's mischief to belittle Ambedkar
- Short Rejoinder to Amit Mitra on Diesel Price Hike...
- Full transcript: NDTV's exclusive interview with S...
- In Modi’s good-governance regime, four villagers e...
- India: Don't change N-liability law to suit MNCs
- Three Dalit youths killed in police firing in Guj ...
- A gangrape, an MMS, a father's suicide: A village ...
- FOREST RIGHTS RALLY- INVITATION - ADHOURA, KAIMUR,...
- Civil society joint open letter to the Commonwealt...
- Assam Accord, a pernicious deception
- Invitation to a ‘PEOPLE’S HEARING ON FABRICATED CA...
- In Haryana, Dalit woman gang-raped at gunpoint, th...
- Fwd: ZIMA Weekly
- Fwd: FW: Important Announcement - Mountain Festiva...
- Fwd: tribute to poof. Banwarilal Sharma
- Save Corporate India UPA Mission
- राष्ट्रीय मानवाधिकार आयोग की ओर से हिंदू और मुसलमा...
- हिन्दू और मुस्लिम के बीच साफ साफ भेद भा
- Fwd: Press release - illegal mining in forest land...
- If Black Money comes back to India
- Fwd: FW: If Black Money comes back to India
- गरीब जिये या मरे, उससे बाजार और राजनीति का क्या!
- ममता के बाद ऐसे बनी बात Tuesday, 25 September 2012...
- गरीब जिये या मरे, उससे बाजार और राजनीति का क्या!
- Provided Mamata is honest enough to lead anti FDI ...
- Fwd: [New post] अनियोजित नहीं है आग्रह पूर्वाग्रह
- Fwd: a report on movement against fake encounter i...
- Fwd: (हस्तक्षेप.कॉम) आप नहीं चाहेंगे तो भी मौसम बद...
-
▼
September
(259)
No comments:
Post a Comment