Is Jordan heading for chaos?
The royal court's unwillingness to make real constitutional reforms increases the risk of further unrest and its own removal
Samer Libdeh
guardian.co.uk, Saturday 29 September 2012 10.00 BST
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2012/sep/29/jordan-heading-chaos
As the impact of the Arab spring continues to be felt across many parts of the Middle East, the Jordanian regime's unwillingness to heed calls for meaningful political reform, greater press freedoms and democratisation is antagonising political and civil society activists alike.
While protests and demonstrations in Jordan have been small and relatively peaceful compared with those in other countries in the region, the royal court's continued intransigence could lead to further unrest, including violent clashes with security forces.
In what was widely seen as an effort to stamp out criticism of the royal court, the Jordanian parliament which consists mainly of conservative pro-regime members recently passed a controversial press and publications law that requires online media organisations to register and obtain licences from the authorities.
In addition, online publishers will be held accountable for comments posted by readers on their website and they will be prohibited from publishing comments that are not strictly relevant to the published article (how this is to be determined is far from clear). This law is clearly designed to limit the dissemination of political commentary that may be critical of the regime.
Although the royal court has in recent months proposed changes to the constitution and the electoral law, these have largely been dismissed as a cosmetic exercise since the king will retain the power to dismiss parliament at will and the proposed new electoral system is still rigged in favour of regime supporters.
In addition, the majority of Jordanians (ie Palestinian-Jordanians) will be significantly under-represented in the parliament. The leading opposition group in Jordan, the Islamic Action Front (IAF the Jordanian Muslim Brotherhood) has vowed to boycott legislative elections planned for early next year and has called for a mass rally to take place in early October.
The IAF is demanding meaningful constitutional amendments to reduce the powers of the king and to amend the current electoral system, which mainly benefits regime supporters. Additionally, influential Transjordanian tribes have been calling for anti-corruption measures as well as amendments to the constitution to give further powers to the parliament.
While there have not been calls for the abolition of the monarchy, the royal court's refusal to properly engage with the protesters is likely to increase tension in the kingdom and could ultimately lead to calls for the removal of the king.
The royal court has a difficult balancing act to perform. First, the protesters are divided. Transjordanians, who have been traditionally loyal to the Hashemite regime, are opposed to political reform that challenges their inherited privileged status and position, and are resisting calls to increase the representation of Palestinian-Jordanians in parliament.
While the king will have to respond to the demands of the IAF and the Palestinian-Jordanians, he will also have to remain sensitive to the needs of the Transjordanians. This will not be an easy task.
Second, if the royal court agrees to real constitutional and political reform there is a risk that the IAF will obtain control of parliament and as a result it would be able to challenge the authority and power of the king for example by introducing further amendments to the constitution.
Third, the Jordanian economy and the royal court's patronage network is largely funded by financial aid from Saudi Arabia, which strongly opposes further democratisation in the Middle East. The royal court is, therefore, coming under pressure from one of its main financial backers to resist calls for political change.
Given the strategic geopolitical importance of the Hashemite kingdom, it is not in the interests of western or regional governments to see Jordan descend into chaos or experience further unrest. So what should be done? A low turnout in the parliamentary elections scheduled to take place later this year under the royal court's new electoral law will be a disaster for the regime and it will raise questions over the legitimacy of the king's reform agenda. Thus the royal court needs to positively engage with protesters and postpone the elections until agreement is reached with stakeholders on political and constitutional reform.
Jordan has the potential to transition to democracy in a more peaceful and organised way by following the Moroccan example. In 2011, the Moroccan monarchy agreed to transfer more powers to parliament, including the authority to form cabinets. This ensured the survival of the monarchy and averted further unrest and violence there.
Unfortunately, it does not appear as if Jordan's king has the vision or the courage to follow this path but failure to learn the lessons of the Arab spring may mean that the Jordanian people will make that decision for him.
Saturday, September 29, 2012
Is Jordan heading for chaos? The royal court's unwillingness to make real constitutional reforms increases the risk of further unrest and its own removal
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Followers
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(6784)
-
▼
September
(259)
- यूपीए और राजग संसदीय नौटंकी के बाद अमेरिकी हितों क...
- Free market economy is injected with reform cromin...
- Naming of Shadman Chowk, Lahore as Bhagat Singh Ch...
- Jal Satyagraha
- In a country where anyone earning Rs 22 per day is...
- Bt.cotton failure : Seven Vidarbha Farmers suicide...
- Egypt, Yemen challenge some U.S. ideas
- As crimes against Dalits rise, UP tops the chart -
- Illegal cracker units exploit Deepavali sales
- Do You Think That America is Not a Police State Yet?
- Nuclear Disarmament Disarmed
- Not vegetarianism or dieting, Mr. Modi INDIRA HIRWAY
- oint letter from Japanese Anti Nuclear Activists a...
- Video:- "The Toronto Hearings on 9/11" - Brilliant
- Dalit kids served injustice at MP school
- Community Formation and Communal Conflict-Namasudr...
- विकास की गंगा की बाढ़ में डूब रहा एक गांव
- शहर और देहात तथा मानसिक श्रम और शारीरिक श्रम के वि...
- Mr. Thackeray! Who is in Whose Land?
- ईमानदारी भुनाने के लिए बाजार चाहिए, वरना जियेंगे क...
- ममता की राजनीति चाहे जो हो,दिल्ली में प्रतिरोध की ...
- No option but to wait for Mamata`s national mass m...
- Fwd: press note by Nikhat Parwen wife of Fashih Ma...
- Fwd: Bhagat Singh Birth celebration in Lahore, pho...
- Fwd: (हस्तक्षेप.कॉम) हे प्रभु भाजपा की रक्षा करना
- बाजरी और हाजरीhttp://www.jansatta.com/index.php/co...
- उत्पीड़न के बहाने
- ‘Perfect storm’ that shook PM Grim alert, bitter p...
- Fw: Press Conference on Hunger Deaths and National...
- Libya: End of the Honeymoon Period
- Egypt's Sinai: The Collapsing Buffer Zone between ...
- UAE Islamist group denies reports it has an armed ...
- Why Qatar wants to invade Syria
- Sectarian Violence in Burma Attracting the Attenti...
- George Habash: A Profile From the Archives
- The plight of the Rif: Morocco's restive northern ...
- Bahrainis battle police in anti-government protests
- Is Jordan heading for chaos? The royal court's unw...
- Analysis: The winds of change in Sudan By Sudan Ch...
- Who are Tunisia's Salafis?
- Saudi Arabia and Qatar Dueling Monarchies Of The M...
- Mauritania: Dreaming about the Fall of the Militar...
- A threat to the entire country Who and what is Bok...
- Rani Rasmani on her 220th birth anniversary
- Rani Rasmani on her 220 th birth anniversary!
- जीने नहीं देती तो सब्सिडी क्यों देती है सरकार
- Cut throat economists push for ethnic cleansing.Co...
- BARVE'S EXPULSION FROM BAMCEF
- हवा और पानी की नीलामी नहीं होगी, यूं ही बेच दी जाय...
- बांग्लादेश में हाशिये पर है हिन्दू आबादी
- Agenda to destroy agrarian India!Land Bill diluted...
- Fwd: [initiative-india] Press Release : MoRD Furth...
- Fwd: Shahid Bhagat Singh's birth anniversary: Pak ...
- Ethnic politics: Baloch, Sindhi and Mohajir moveme...
- s Iraq's Dawa Party Returning To Their Islamist Ro...
- Kenya and its coastal discontents Kenya must make ...
- How to kill the Haqqanis? Work with Iranian terror...
- Outrage at CIA's deadly 'double tap' drone attacks...
- Towards a "Colored Revolution" in Malaysia? US and...
- Egypt Workers Striking in Record Numbers
- Interview with Islamic Group leader Rifai Taha
- Could Benghazi Embassy Deaths Be a Harbinger of Al...
- 100 Million Dead, Trillion of Dollars Lost from Cl...
- FIELD MARSHAL SAM MANEKSHAW’S LECTURE AT DEFENCE S...
- Are you going to Kudankulam?
- India: big bang, or parting shot? By Victor Mallet
- THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS CRITICIZES GOVT ...
- अब बिजली गिरेगी आम आदमी पर! बिजली ग्रिड फेल होने ...
- Deprived of food security in grow
- Fwd: (हस्तक्षेप.कॉम) यूरोपीय विश्व दृष्टि की देन ह...
- Fwd: [initiative-india] NAPM pays respect and homa...
- Fw: [pmarc] Fwd: Gujarat genocide 2002: Commemorat...
- Fw: Hindutva's mischief to belittle Ambedkar
- Short Rejoinder to Amit Mitra on Diesel Price Hike...
- Full transcript: NDTV's exclusive interview with S...
- In Modi’s good-governance regime, four villagers e...
- India: Don't change N-liability law to suit MNCs
- Three Dalit youths killed in police firing in Guj ...
- A gangrape, an MMS, a father's suicide: A village ...
- FOREST RIGHTS RALLY- INVITATION - ADHOURA, KAIMUR,...
- Civil society joint open letter to the Commonwealt...
- Assam Accord, a pernicious deception
- Invitation to a ‘PEOPLE’S HEARING ON FABRICATED CA...
- In Haryana, Dalit woman gang-raped at gunpoint, th...
- Fwd: ZIMA Weekly
- Fwd: FW: Important Announcement - Mountain Festiva...
- Fwd: tribute to poof. Banwarilal Sharma
- Save Corporate India UPA Mission
- राष्ट्रीय मानवाधिकार आयोग की ओर से हिंदू और मुसलमा...
- हिन्दू और मुस्लिम के बीच साफ साफ भेद भा
- Fwd: Press release - illegal mining in forest land...
- If Black Money comes back to India
- Fwd: FW: If Black Money comes back to India
- गरीब जिये या मरे, उससे बाजार और राजनीति का क्या!
- ममता के बाद ऐसे बनी बात Tuesday, 25 September 2012...
- गरीब जिये या मरे, उससे बाजार और राजनीति का क्या!
- Provided Mamata is honest enough to lead anti FDI ...
- Fwd: [New post] अनियोजित नहीं है आग्रह पूर्वाग्रह
- Fwd: a report on movement against fake encounter i...
- Fwd: (हस्तक्षेप.कॉम) आप नहीं चाहेंगे तो भी मौसम बद...
-
▼
September
(259)
No comments:
Post a Comment